“A Case Against Beauty” by Lily Seibel

Have you ever taken a moment to think and noticed that the highest compliment we pay nature is to call it beautiful? Often times, it is the only word that comes to mind when surveying a particularly picturesque landscape. There are dozens of equally eloquent synonyms, but, at the end of the day, beautiful is the word we give out as the most esteemed prize. We all want to be beautiful. It is a uniquely human obsession; we spend our lives desperate to be found pleasing to the eye. People who have the assets spend tens of thousands to make themselves look as close to the ever-shifting ideal as possible. When we die, our corpses are “made-up,” lest we be ugly even in death. Heaven forbid the grieving family be traumatized by the true and lifeless face of their deceased. 

As my grandmother lay in her hospital bed, worn out from many long months spent sick, her sister washed and combed her hair every day, helping her to look as nice as possible. When I asked my aunt why, her answer was simple. “Dignity,” she said, and though her voice was tired I could tell what it meant to her. But is it undignified to fight, undignified to look worse for the wear from your efforts? And do we not treat the scenery around us the same way, preferring to turn our heads away from ugly realities? We would rather not look at oceans filled with plastic, roadsides littered with garbage, brown and muddied rivers. Instead we seek out the beautiful. We search for images of sparkling, crystalline waters bordering clean, healthy stretches of sun-kissed sand. 

Writers and poets throughout the ages have hailed beauty as the meaning of life, the manifestation of God, and the answer to all questions unasked. But is it not a concept of our own creation? Do the birds in the treetops waste the dawn marveling at the sunrise? In our search for understanding, we have clung to this misguided idea. The only way to truly appreciate nature in its fullness is to move beyond that weak, shallow abstraction. To abandon our search for beauty is to open ourselves up to entirely new and life-changing perceptions. We can embrace the ugly, and move past it to focus on the impact nature has on us, rather than strictly the physical presence of it. The physical presence of nature always looks pale in comparison to the feelings that surface.

On my birthday weekend, we had followed the tour guide into Crystal Cave and gazed around in awe as she named and spouted off information about the rock formations around us. Stalactites clung to the ceiling of the cavern and hung down, nurturing the stalagmites that were slowly growing up in hopes of one day meeting, two halves made whole after a lifetime of uncertain reaching. “It can take hundreds of thousands of years to form a column,” our guide informs us, “if they can manage to go untouched.” And so the beauty of these living rocks is their own downfall. Some formations looked uncannily like icing, leaving me wondering how they convince younger children passing through to keep themselves from trying to steal a taste. Although the cave was certainly an interesting and deeply intriguing sight, the most impactful part of the trip was soon to come. 

In a relatively flat, more open area, the tour guide turned off the lights in the cavern and for a few long, timeless minutes we stood in complete darkness. I thought that I could just about see the hazy outline of my mother standing in front of me, but when I waved my hand in front of my face I could not detect even a hint of movement. I was well and truly blind. I let my eyes flutter closed, shielding myself from the piercing nothingness and appreciating the tentative silence that was looming. In that moment, I felt a chill creep down my spine, not from the coolness of the air, but from the undeniable sense that I was standing inside of a living thing, intruding where I did not yet belong. It was both a womb and a tomb, the guts of the earth and the grave of her creatures. If I listened very closely, beyond the quiet breathing of our group and the occasional ping of water striking the floor from an uncertain location, I could almost hear the voice of the cave. Someday, I could imagine her saying, you will be home here. Your bones will be tender companions to the rocks.

I was reluctantly pulled away from the soft, comforting promise by the return of the lights. I saw the cave with fresh eyes then, past the beauty of the stone and into the heart of the place. Had I not been plunged into absolute darkness, would I have been able to sense the nature of the cavern?

Despite this jarring experience, it’s not always necessary to block out the sight of a location to feel its profound impact. Acknowledging the magnificent appearance of a place is not the problem; it is stopping at the appearance. Sometimes it’s enough to open yourself up to the energy of the land around you and connect with it. When I stood atop Hawk Mountain and admired the nearby peaks, I could tell that it was more than beautiful. It was sacred, a living part of the body of the earth. Coated in trees, dressed in all shades of green, I could picture them rising and falling as the world drew in and released a leisurely breath. I felt deeply at peace, soothed by the certainty the mountains were alive around us. We are existing on the back of this living creature, and in light of that the concerns and worries of our everyday life feel insignificant and far away. We are never alone; we are small pieces in a much larger system. 

Sometimes this realization does not come in as pleasant a manner as we might like. As I walk along the side of the road, my pace fast and my mind fixed on the destination, I am shaken from my reverie by a common and gruesome sight. About a dozen feet in front of me is a deer, twisted and lifeless on the unforgiving asphalt. A few dark birds take communion in its spilled entrails, no doubt grateful for their meal. I am frozen in place as I gaze into the wide and empty eyes of the fallen animal, and I find that I understand. I am the crows; I am the fawn; I am the car that killed it. For just a second, as I am immersed in the scene, I almost want to call it beautiful. But that would be an injustice, a criminal oversimplification. The understanding is a gift not to be taken lightly. 

One of the greatest gifts nature has given me came on one warm August morning on a beach in Virginia, when I saw, for the first time, the sun rising over the Atlantic Ocean. Although my parents are Christian, and raised me in the church, I don’t think I had ever truly felt religion until that day. It was our first morning of vacation, and I had set a multitude of alarms and made a point to rise early enough to see it. I had skipped between the rows of houses towards the beach giddily, humming with excitement for the experience I was about to have. I had seen pictures before, of all different oceans from all different angles, but none of them could have prepared me. 

The spectacular, vivid colors bleeding across the broken surface, the constant, volatile movement of the water, and the choking stench of fish and salt were incredibly overwhelming. At that moment, I did not think it was beautiful. I couldn’t think of anything at first. I had used the term speechless before, but I had never really experienced it until that moment. There were no words that could come close to describing the wave of emotions that crashed over me and threatened to pull me apart at the seams. I had always expected my first time seeing the ocean to be a happy experience, but I found myself unhinged; desperation and longing and absolution mixed together until my feelings were as murky and difficult to pull apart as the colors on the opaque canvas in front of me. It took me several moments to even realize that I had sunk down to sit in the sand. I looked at the sun reflected on the water, and I saw in the wispy image the sum of our history: past, present, and future. 

We can never know for certain, but it is believed that life, as we understand it, first began near hydrothermal vents deep within the ocean. The uniquely suited environment gave rise to the first cells and over time periods too vast to really grasp, those cells evolved and diverged into all the beings on earth today, and many that did not make it to this day. Some kept close to their home in the water while others made their way to the land, developing legs and lungs in the process. The sun played an indispensable role. It provided the warmth, light, and radiation necessary to allow for life to make its progress from the depths to the surface. It is bittersweet and perhaps fitting, then, that on one far-away day the very sun that nursed and nourished us will consume us. The earth and everything on it reduced to ashes. And then, as part of the cycle of life that extends beyond what we may consider to be life, the sun will burn out and die. Only dust and gas will be left, existing suspended in the cold, uncaring vacuum of space until eventually becoming part of another star. 

Between those two monumental events we are trapped in our present. Though one day there will be only the component particles that once made up our solar system left to tell our story, what we do now still matters. We have separated ourselves from our home, from our origin, and built up a wall between ourselves and the world around us. We’ve stolen and exploited and destroyed without thought of the consequences, without consideration of the life around us. It is time to break free of this delusion of separation and accept that we and nature are one and the same. We cannot kill the earth without killing ourselves. 

By reducing the landscape and life around us to beautiful, we have made it too easy to disregard that simple fact. We have made it passive, something to be admired from a distance and shelved away when we are done looking. We have coped with our poisoning of the world around us by reducing it to a pleasing sight, nothing more and nothing less. In doing so we have loosened our connection to the energy of the landscape. It often takes conscious effort now to reach out and experience the offerings that we were once so acutely attuned to. Humans are animals, too, and we are no better than those around us. We are part of the environment, part of the ecosystem. We must protect the earth, our home and our mother, not because she is beautiful, but because she is deserving of the same dignity that we are, and she has so much more depth that we have only just scratched the surface of. It is time to put to rest our search for idolatry and beauty. It is time to turn instead towards connection and understanding.


Lily Seibel is a junior public health major with an interest in epidemiology and environmental health. This is her first published piece, written for the Nature and Environmental Writing course. In writing this, and several other works for the aforementioned class, she discovered a passion for nature writing that she hopes to explore further in the coming years.